FROM OUR PARTNERS

Best Pet Insurance in Buffalo, NY of 2025

Lisa Scott

When it comes to taking care of our beloved pets, we want to make sure they have the best possible care. This includes not only regular check-ups and vaccinations, but also insurance coverage in case of unexpected accidents or illnesses. Pet insurance in Buffalo, New York can provide peace of mind and financial protection for pet owners.

Super-extensive accident & illness coverage

$20,000

Coverage Up To

90%

Reimbursement

Overview

Pumpkin offers high-quality pet insurance plans for cats and dogs as well as an optional non-insurance preventive care plan for vaccinations, key tests and wellness exams, which will help to keep your pet happy and healthy through their life. You can travel with your pet in Canada or the US and can get access from any licensed vet in these countries. The platform is entirely digitized and serves as a one-stop-shop for all your pet's healthcare needs.

Pumpkin will cover up to $20,000 for dogs and $15,000 for cats annually.

What we like

  • Extensive coverage on multiple health issues
  • Optional preventive care plan that reimburses in full for annual wellness exams and vaccines
  • No exclusion on breeds or older pets
  • Offers a Fur Family Discount on multiple pets
  • Healthcare coverage in Canada and the US

What we don't

  • Pre-existing health conditions not covered
  • Pumpkin only covers dogs and cats

Pumpkin Advertiser Disclosure: Pumpkin Pet Insurance policies do not cover pre-existing conditions. Waiting periods, annual deductible, co-insurance, benefit limits and exclusions may apply. For full terms, visit pumpkin.care/insurancepolicy. Products, discounts, and rates may vary and are subject to change. Pumpkin Insurance Services Inc. (“Pumpkin”) (NPN #19084749) is a licensed insurance agency, not an insurer. Insurance is underwritten by United States Fire Insurance Company, a Crum & Forster Company (NAIC #21113, Morristown, NJ) and produced by Pumpkin. Pumpkin Preventive Essentials is not an insurance policy. It is offered as an optional add-on non-insurance benefit. Pumpkin is responsible for the product and administration. Pumpkin Preventive Essentials is not available in all states. For full terms, visit pumpkin.care/customeragreement. Paid Endorsement.

Multiple options for wellness plans

$100,000

Coverage Up To

90% - 100%

Reimbursement Rates

Overview

Wagmo began by providing stand-alone pet wellness coverages. Today, it has expanded its portfolio to include customizable pet insurance coverage.

What we like

  • Customizable policies
  • Variety of wellness plans
  • Fast reimbursements
  • High incident limits
  • Visit a vet of your choice

What we don't

  • 15 day waiting period on accident policy

Affordable prices with a fast reimbursement process

$100,000

Coverage Up To

70% - 90%

Reimbursement

Overview

Lemonade has earned a stellar reputation in the pet insurance industry with its affordable monthly premiums and fast reimbursement of claims with its AI technology. This technology has attracted thousands with its customizable policies and provides comprehensive coverage on illness and accidents to dogs and cats.

What we like

  • Customizable plans so you only pay for coverage that your pet needs
  • Claims are reimbursed in minutes
  • Affordable monthly premiums starting at $10/month
  • Comprehensive wellness plans to keep your pet in good health
  • Pay deductible once per year and not per incident

What we don't

  • Lemonade is only available in 33 states
  • Certain hybrid breeds may be denied

Short waiting periods on accidental coverage

$25,000

Coverage Up To

50% - 100%

Reimbursement

Overview

MetLife Insurance offers pet insurance for cats and dogs and is known for the shortest waiting periods in the industry.

What we like

  • No restriction on breeds and pet age
  • Customizable annual benefit limits
  • Short waiting periods accidental coverage
  • Flexible deductibles from $50 to $2,000
  • No incident limits

What we don't

  • Wellness treatment not included (optional add-on)
  • Pay first out of pocket and reimbursed later

Quick claims process

$10,000

Coverage Up To

70% - 90%

Reimbursement

Overview

Spot will insure older animals and provides a multi-pet discount when you insure two or more pets

What we like

  • Multi-pet discount
  • No upper age limit
  • Quick claims process
  • Fast and simple filing of claims
  • Optional no lifetime limits or caps on payouts

What we don't

  • Customer service limited to weekdays
  • 14 day waiting period

Pre-existing conditions and 6 pets covered for $24/m

$3,000

Coverage Up To

100%

Reimbursement

Overview

Pawp offers pet owners an emergency fund up to but not exceeding $3,000 annually. The platform is different from other traditional pet insurance agencies as it does not require you to provide a medical examination report before enrolling your pet. Whether your pet is healthy or has been diagnosed with a pre-existing condition, you can still enroll it and access the emergency fund when the need arises.

With no deductibles and low monthly premiums as low as $24, the digital platform will protect your furry friend during an incident and save money from large vet expenses. Although the agency does not provide any limitations on age, it is best to insure your pet while still young and be prepared in advance when an emergency occurs.

What we like

  • Monthly premiums as low as $24
  • Allows coverage on 6 pets for $24 a month
  • Allows enrollment of pets with pre-existing conditions
  • 24/7 unlimited access to Pawp’s virtual vet doctors

What we don't

  • Coverage is restricted to healthcare emergencies only
  • Does not offer wellness coverage
  • Emergency funds can be accessed only once per year

Provides holistic therapy coverage

$15,000

Coverage Up To

70% - 90%

Reimbursement

Overview

Fetch covers various conditions and offers holistic therapy coverage.

What we like

  • Covers examination fee during vet visits
  • Holistic therapy coverage
  • Comprehensive dental coverage
  • No penalty for multiple claims
  • No upper age limit for the pets

What we don't

  • Offers a single plan
  • No preventive care plans
  • No multi-pet discount

No age limit on pets - older dogs and cats are covered

Unlimited

Coverage Up To

70% - 90%

Reimbursement Rates

Overview

Prudent pet has excellent coverage for your pet regardless of their age. The insurer can customize your plan from illnesses, medications, accidents to preventive care that will fit your pet's needs and financial situation. This plan will give you peace of mind that you won't break the bank with unlimited coverage if an emergency occurs since treatments tend to be more expensive for older pets.

What we like

  • Older cats and dogs are covered
  • Customize your plan to fit your pet's needs and financial situation
  • Customers from US can get covered in Canada as well
  • Unlimited live vet chat if an issue occurs with your pet
  • 10% multiple pets discount

What we don't

  • Pre-existing health conditions not covered
  • Wellness add-ons can get expensive

Why you need pet insurance

Just like human health insurance, pet insurance can help cover the cost of unexpected medical expenses for your furry friend. Accidents and illnesses can happen at any time, and without insurance, the cost of treatment can be overwhelming. Pet insurance can also cover routine care, such as vaccinations and preventative treatments.

Additionally, many pet insurance policies offer coverage for things like prescription medication, behavioral therapy, and even alternative therapies like acupuncture or chiropractic care. Having insurance can provide access to a wider range of treatments and give you the freedom to choose the best options for your pet’s health.

Types of pet insurance available

When it comes to pet insurance, there are a few different types available. The most common types include:

  • Accident-only coverage: This type of insurance only covers accidental injuries, such as broken bones or lacerations.
  • Time-limited coverage: This type of insurance covers a specific illness or injury for a set period of time, usually 12 months.
  • Lifetime coverage: This type of insurance covers an illness or injury for the life of the pet, as long as the policy is kept in force.

Another important aspect to consider is the type of reimbursement offered. Some policies offer reimbursement based on actual veterinary bills, while others offer a set amount per incident or per condition. It’s important to understand how your policy works so you can budget accordingly.

Exclusions and limitations

Like any insurance policy, there are exclusions and limitations to be aware of when it comes to pet insurance. These can include:

  • Pre-existing conditions: Many policies will not cover illnesses or injuries that existed before the policy was purchased.
  • Waiting periods: Some policies have waiting periods before coverage begins, during which time certain illnesses or injuries will not be covered.
  • Age limits: Some policies have age limits for coverage, and will not cover pets over a certain age.

It’s important to fully understand the exclusions and limitations of any pet insurance policy before purchasing.

Comparing different policies

When looking for pet insurance in Buffalo, New York, it’s important to compare different policies to find the best one for you and your pet. Some things to consider when comparing policies include:

  • Coverage: Make sure the policy covers the types of treatment you may need for your pet.
  • Reimbursement: Consider how the policy reimburses you for veterinary bills and whether it works with your budget.
  • Exclusions and limitations: Be aware of any exclusions or limitations that may affect your coverage.
  • Customer service: Look for a company with good customer service so you can get help and support when you need it.

Cost of pet insurance

When it comes to pet insurance, the cost can vary depending on a variety of factors, such as the type of coverage, the age of the pet, and the breed. It’s important to understand the cost of pet insurance and how it may affect your budget.

Many pet insurance companies offer different plans with varying levels of coverage and cost. Some policies may have a higher monthly premium but lower deductibles, while others may have a lower monthly premium but higher deductibles.

It’s also important to consider any additional costs, such as co-pays or co-insurance, that may be required by the policy. By understanding the cost and comparing different plans, you can find the best pet insurance for your budget.

Discounts and benefits

Many pet insurance companies offer discounts and benefits for their policyholders. These can include:

  • Multi-pet discounts: Many companies offer discounts for insuring multiple pets at once.
  • Loyalty discounts: Some companies offer discounts for policyholders who renew their coverage year after year.
  • Wellness coverage: Some policies offer coverage for routine care, such as vaccinations and preventative treatments, as part of their coverage.

Additionally, some companies may offer additional benefits, such as lost pet recovery services or 24/7 telemedicine consultations. By looking for discounts and benefits, you can save money and get more value out of your pet insurance policy.

It’s also important to check if your employer offers any pet insurance benefits, as many companies provide coverage as part of their employee benefits package. By taking advantage of discounts and benefits, you can find the best pet insurance that fits your budget and provides the best possible care for your pet.

How to choose the best pet insurance in Buffalo

Choosing the best pet insurance in Buffalo, New York can be a daunting task, but by considering the coverage, reimbursement, exclusions and limitations, and customer service of different policies, you can find the right one for you and your pet.

It’s also important to consult with your veterinarian before making a decision. They can provide valuable insight and recommendations based on your pet’s specific needs and medical history.

Ultimately, having pet insurance can provide peace of mind and financial protection for pet owners, allowing them to focus on providing the best possible care for their furry friends.


Ultimate Guide to Keep Your Pet Happy and Healthy
Learn how to provide the best care for your furry friend with practical tips and expert advice in this FREE comprehensive e-book.
GET THE EBOOK